When to stop and get medical care. Some symptoms need a doctor, not a routine. Contact a medical provider promptly if you have severe abdominal pain; fever or persistent vomiting; rectal bleeding or black, tarry stool; unexplained weight loss; a new, unexplained change in bowel habits, especially from age 45 onward; or recent abdominal surgery within the last six weeks. If symptoms are severe, call your physician or go to the emergency department.
In my practice, people tell me they push because they assume it’s a matter of effort. What they usually don’t realize is that the exit has to let go, and pushing harder doesn’t make it.
Why pushing harder can work against you
In a coordinated bowel movement, pressure inside the abdomen rises while the pelvic floor relaxes and the sling around the rectum lets go, which straightens the angle between the rectum and the anal canal, the anorectal angle. I walk through the full sequence in how bowel movements actually work.
When that sequence breaks down, pushing harder can work against you. Clinicians who retrain this coordination coach people not to push too hard, because it is often counterproductive. Straining has more than one source, and a coordination problem at the exit is one of them.
The criteria gastroenterologists use list straining in more than a quarter of bowel movements as one of the signs of constipation. By those criteria, a diagnosis rests on two or more signs, not on any one of them alone.
What changes on the toilet
Sitting with your knees higher than your hips and your trunk leaning slightly forward changes the geometry at the exit. The sling can relax more fully and the angle opens, where a standard seated position leaves it partly kinked. Whether that makes a bowel movement easier is a separate question, and the studies answer it differently for different groups of people.
In healthy volunteers, squatting cut the time they needed to feel emptied and lowered the effort they rated, compared with sitting. That study tested squatting, not a footstool, and the volunteers recorded the results themselves.
In a small randomized trial of people referred to a specialty unit with constipation, a footstool changed posture but did not improve a simulated evacuation test, on the clock or in how the test felt. In a review of clinic records from a referral center, a footstool turned a failed simulated test into a pass for a minority of the people with a defecation disorder who had failed it.
When a footstool does not help, posture was not the missing piece.
Don’t sit and push for long. Retraining for a coordination problem teaches a moderate push, not sustained straining.
My own instruction: breathe out rather than holding your breath and bearing down. How the diaphragm and the pelvic floor move together is covered in using breathwork and movement to encourage motility.
When it isn’t posture
Hard stool is a question about time spent in the colon, and what hard, dry stool is telling you covers that side. Soft stool that is still hard to pass points toward the exit instead.
When the pelvic floor tightens instead of releasing during a bowel movement, clinicians call it dyssynergic defecation. Sustained stress is one thing that can keep the pelvic floor braced.
A coordination problem at the exit is found with testing, not guessed at: symptoms alone cannot tell it apart from slow transit, where stool moves slowly through the colon.
Biofeedback is a form of retraining in which a monitor and a therapist’s coaching show what the push and the muscles at the exit are doing, so a person can learn to coordinate them. A consensus guideline on biofeedback recommends it for adults whose constipation comes from this coordination problem, at its top grade. The American College of Gastroenterology guideline calls it the cornerstone of management, and notes that most studies show benefit in the short term while the evidence for longer-term benefit is of low quality.
In my practice, I refer to a pelvic floor specialist when the trouble looks like it’s at the exit: straining is the main complaint, or the stool is soft and still hard to pass.
Signs that need a doctor
Minor bleeding can come from hemorrhoids during straining, but unexplained bleeding or dark, tarry stool needs prompt investigation. Severe abdominal pain, unexplained weight loss, or a new, unexplained change in bowel habits, especially from age 45 onward, also need a doctor rather than a routine. A new change at any age deserves attention. The full list is in when to stop self-managing and see a doctor.
The key takeaway
Pushing harder does not open an exit that has not let go. If changing how you sit does not help, the next step is finding out what is getting in the way, not more effort.
Still straining, even when you change how you sit?
If you are still straining after you change how you sit, a discovery call is a free, short conversation about what might be getting in the way. Book one at dryarondaom.com/discovery.
Dr. Yaron practices in Maryland, Virginia, DC, Georgia, and New York.
References
- Lacy BE, Mearin F, Chang L, Chey WD, Lembo AJ, Simren M, Spiller R. Bowel Disorders. Gastroenterology. 2016;150(6):1393-1407.e5. PMID: 27144627.
- Rao SSC, Patcharatrakul T. Diagnosis and Treatment of Dyssynergic Defecation. J Neurogastroenterol Motil. 2016;22(3):423-435. PMID: 27270989.
- Rao SS, Benninga MA, Bharucha AE, Chiarioni G, Di Lorenzo C, Whitehead WE. ANMS-ESNM position paper and consensus guidelines on biofeedback therapy for anorectal disorders. Neurogastroenterol Motil. 2015;27(5):594-609. PMID: 25828100.
- Sikirov D. Comparison of straining during defecation in three positions: results and implications for human health. Dig Dis Sci. 2003;48(7):1201-1205. PMID: 12870773.
- Trieu RQ, Prott G, Sequeira C, et al. Using a footstool does not aid simulated defecation in undifferentiated constipation: A randomized trial. Neurogastroenterol Motil. 2023;35(7):e14580. PMID: 36989181.
- Ulsh L, Halawi H, Triadafilopoulos G, et al. Use of a footstool improves rectal balloon expulsion in some patients with defecatory disorders. Neurogastroenterol Motil. 2024;36(7):e14781. PMID: 38488172.
- Wald A, Bharucha AE, Limketkai B, et al. ACG Clinical Guidelines: Management of Benign Anorectal Disorders. Am J Gastroenterol. 2021;116(10):1987-2008. PMID: 34618700.
DISCLAIMER: The information in this article is for educational purposes only and does not constitute medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Dr. Yaron Cohen is a licensed acupuncturist and a doctor of acupuncture and Oriental medicine (DAOM) practicing integrative care. This content is general health education. It is not a substitute for consultation, diagnosis, or treatment from your physician or another qualified healthcare provider, and reading it does not create a patient-practitioner relationship. Individual medical needs vary. Always consult your physician about any medical condition, symptoms, or treatment options. Do not start, stop, or change any prescribed medication, and do not change any treatment directed by your physician, based on information you have read here. Do not disregard or delay seeking professional medical advice because of something you have read here.